China’s Covid-19 about-face: From 'sick man of Asia' to 'savior of the world'
China has stepped up the propaganda accompanying its global distribution of face masks and other medical equipment. After accusations of being the source of the virus, Beijing is trying to turn the tide using aggressive counter-arguments while flooding infected countries with what is sometimes unusable equipment.
On the day that China commemorates its dead (see box below) Beijing claims it has the coronavirus crisis under control, that deaths are close to zero, and that the only new cases are people who entered China from abroad.
But critics question the veracity of China’s official claims and figures, and a renewed lockdown of certain areas, including the epicenter Wuhan last week suggests that the virus is far from being under control.
Now, both China and the US are using the coronavirus pandemic as a tool of propaganda in an increasingly nasty war of words.
China came to a standstill on April 4, “tomb sweeping day,” traditionally the day to mourn the dead. This year, the day is dedicated to mourn patients and medical staff killed by the coronavirus by a nationwide three-minute silence.
At 10 am local time, citizens paused, cars, trains and ships sounded their horns, and air-raid sirens rang out in memory of the more than 3,000 lives claimed by the virus in China.
In Wuhan, where the virus was first reported in December, sirens and horns sounded as people fell silent in the streets.
Staff at the Tongji Hospital stood outside with heads bowed toward the main building, some in the protective hazmat suits that have become a symbol of the crisis worldwide.
"I feel a lot of sorrow about our colleagues and patients who died," Xu, a nurse at Tongji who worked on the frontlines treating coronavirus patients, told AFP, holding back tears.
Regular “tomb sweeping” activities are suspended out of hygiene concerns. Cemeteries across China are offering a "cloud tomb-sweeping" service in which families can honour their ancestors by watching a live stream of cemetery staff attending to graves on their behalf.
Websites are also offering people the chance to pay their respects at a "virtual" tomb, including by lighting a digital candle and leaving a dish of digital fruit.
Chinese scientists did report the outbreak
In spite of sharp US criticism, China did report the virus early. The Wuhan Municipal Health Commission (WMHC) did start reporting to the WHO on “a pulmonary disease” in a first statement on December 31, 2019, saying that 27 people had been infected after being in contact with the Huanan Fresh Seafood Market.
The market was closed on January 1. On January 5, Chinese scientists published the complete genome of what they called the "Wuhan seafood market pneumonia virus isolate Wuhan-Hu-1," identifying it as a “novel coronavirus.”
In a fifth report on January 11, the WMHC said that 41 cases were found between December 8 and January 2, but that after January 3, no new cases were detected.
The WHO then issued a statement on January 12 saying that 41 cases of coronavirus were diagnosed of which one person died.
Meanwhile, Chinese scientists, who initially named the virus the “WH (Wuhan)-Human 1” virus had submitted a deep digging report on January 7, which was published by Nature magazine at the beginning of February.
The article describes samples taken from a 41 year old man who was working at the Wuhan Huanan Fresh Seafood market, showing a 91% similarity to a SARS-like coronavirus that is found in bats. An article by 28 Chinese virologists published on 24 January by The Lancet, details test results on the 41 positive cases.
Three days after the article in Nature, Dr. Xiao Botao from the South China University of Technology in Guangzhou, and Dr. Xiao Lei, from Wuhan University of Science and Technology, published an article describing a researcher who was “once attacked by a bat and the blood of the bat shot on his skin,” after which he self-isolated for 14 days.
It also states that experiments with bats were performed in the Wuhan Center for Disease Control and Prevention, which is only 280 meters away from the Seafood Market.
“Speculation was that Sars-CoV or its derivative might leak from the laboratory,” writes Xiao, adding that “in addition to origins of natural recombination and intermediate host, the killer virus probably originated from a laboratory in Wuhan.”
... but the government played them down
But after stern denials by China's state media and a letter, published on 19 February in The Lancet, signed by 27 scientists saying that "conspiracy theories do nothing but create fear, rumours, and prejudice that jeopardise our global collaboration in the fight against this virus," Beijing quickly cracked down.
The article by Xiao Botao and Xiao Lei disappeared from the international academic data base Research Gate, but can be re-traced through the Wayback Machine, the Internet’s archive.
Xiao Botao told the Wall Street Journal in an email on 26 February that he had had withdrawn his paper, saying that “the speculation about the possible origins in the post was based on published papers and media, and was not supported by direct proofs.”
At the same time, authorities muzzled whistleblowing doctors, until one of them, Li Wenliang died, causing a massive outcry on social media leaving Beijing no other option than admitting the problem.
The China National Health Commission started to publish daily updates of newly infected cases, death rates and recoveries, numbers that peaked at the end of February, causing another about-face. After President Xi Jinping’s visit to Wuhan on March 10, China turned from patient to doctor, exporting millions of face masks, tens of thousands of ventilators accompanied by medical personnel, initially to its Belt and Road allies, later also to more sceptical partners, such as France and the US.
The People’s Republic Strikes Back
After China's about-face and the spread of the virus to virtually all other countries in the world, Beijing faced increasing criticism by the US and some of its Western allies.
US diplomats, following President Donald Trump’s criticism on China, launched a volley of criticism against Beijing, accusing it of “lack of transparency” and reporting the virus too late.
Zhao Lijian, an official spokesperson for the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, suggested that the virus may have originated in the US, and his remarks were echoed by ambassadors worldwide.
China expelled three Wall Street Journal reporters after the newspaper ran an article saying that "China is the real sick man of Asia" and increasedfootage of the bulky Russian Antonov 124 planes that brought millions of face masks, medical equipment, doctors and nurses to the worst hit areas.
Critics not silenced
China’s global effort to “face mask diplomacy” are met with mixed reactions. Where China’s propaganda machine shows the triumphant arrival of pallets packed with face masks being received by happy crowds in countries from Serbia to Rwanda, not everybody is enthusiastic.
The Dutch government had to call back 600.000 FFP2 masks after they were tested and appeared to fail hygiene standards while The Australian Border police confiscated 800.000 face masks that were “counterfeit or otherwise faulty” according to a report by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Spain and Turkey had to send back large shipments as well. China rejected the complaints, saying they were "politically motivated."
But EU high representative for foreign policy, Josep Borrell commented on his blog countered that there was indeed a “geopolitical component” to the Covid-19 crisis, including a “struggle for influence through spinning and the ‘politics of generosity’”.
He added that China was “sending equipment and doctors to Europe” and “aggressively pushing the message that, unlike the US, it is a responsible and reliable partner.”
Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morningSubscribe