Skip to main content

French press review 7 November 2018

4 min

Have the interstellar neighbours been snooping? Does the moderate left have a political future in France? More on those American midterm elections.


Just to give you a break from those American midterm elections, news from Le Monde's science pages that two scientists from the highly respected Harvard university in the United States think we're not alone in the universe.

The two dudes claim that the cigar-shaped Oumuamua asteroid, which passed through our solar system in 2017 was actually an exploratory device sent by an extraterrestrial civilisation. "Oumuamua" means "messenger" in Hawaian.

The asteroid in question was 400m long and about 40 wide and was tracked by several telescopes. It was widely celebrated as the first object to have reached our corner of space from another stellar system.

After careful consideration, the asteroid was downgraded to a comet. In other words, from mini-planet status to a mere ball of ice and dust. It did not appear to be emitting signals.

Now, in this month's edition of the prestigious Astrophysical Journal, the two scientists, one of them the head of Harvard's astronomy department, suggest that Oumuamua could have been a fully operational research device sent close to Earth by some far-away space neighbours.

They base this claim on the comet's remarkably high speed. Not big enough to profit from the energy provided by solar radiation, Oumuamua could travel that fast only if it had engines, say the two researchers.

Other scientists' incredulity

The rest of the scientific community has reacted with incredulity, to say the best of it.

Alan Fitzsimmons of Queen's University, Belfast, says the idea is hogwash. Katie Mack from North Carolina State University reminds us that scientists can publish the most ridiculous hypotheses, provided that there's at least a tiny chance they could be right.

We'll never know for sure. Oumuamua has continued past Earth on its interstellar journey and won't be back.

Is Public Space the future of the French left?

Left-leaning Libération looks ahead to next month's elections in Togo, unlikely to dislodge the Gnassingbé dynasty which has been in power now for more than half a century.

And Libé gives the front-page honours to "Public Space", the new left-wing movement here in France which is trying to pull together the tatters of old socialism with an eye on next year's European elections. It's not just for the left. In an echo of the inclusiveness which won the presidency for Emmanuel Macron, Public Space is open to "everyone," especially those who worry about the environment, who fear economic liberalism, who aren't scared of migrants.

Libération's editorial says this could signal the rebirth of French socialism or a further division of the already micro-fine leftist electorate. But you have to start somewhere.

Meanwhile, what's happening in America?

Le Figaro's web edition is reacting to the results of the American midterms as they come in.

The French conservative paper notes that Donald Trump is, perhaps predictably, hailing the outcome as an enormous vote of confidence in his presidency. He has already collected the unprecedented sum of 106 million dollars (93 million euros) to finance his reelection campaign in 2020.

Le Figaro says that, despite appearances, US Democrats, the closest thing American has to a left-wing movement, are more ideologically divided than their conservative Republican opponents.

The Democrats are certainly helped by the anti-Trump effect, which seems to have got a lot of complacent voters off their arses and into polling booths. It has also kept the money rolling into party campaign coffers. But that doesn't mean that all Democrats stand for the same policies.

For young Democrats, says Le Figaro, the tag "socialist" is no longer a slur; for their parents, socialism is only one step up from the primaeval slime of communism.

Many of America's young, the analysis continues, have come to reject the vision of their parents, based on endless credit, a sort of mortgaging of the future.

Donald Trump, in sharp contrast, seems to have united the normally fractious Republicans behind him, despite his frequent skids and skirmishes. Taxes are down, profits are up, growth is running at 4.1 percent. Brett Kavanaugh is in the Supreme Court. God is in his heaven. Who could ask for better?

Whatever the outcome of this midterm test, says Le Figaro, things are looking good for Trump in the next presidential race.

Which may explain why the extraterrestrial researchers on board Oumuamua took one look and kept going.

Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morning

Page not found

The content you requested does not exist or is not available anymore.