New row erupts over the wearing of the Islamic hijab in public in France
Issued on: Modified:
The debate around women wearing the Islamic headscarf has divided French politicians again, with France’s right wing Senate leader Gérard Larcher calling for President Emmanuel Macron to revise the law when it comes to religious neutrality in schools.
"It’s without a doubt a difficult subject,” Larcher said in an interview with France 2 Television on Tuesday night.
“But it is an essential subject, and we expect the President to federate and to make people of Muslim origin and religion feel just as much as part of the Republic as atheists, Catholics and Jews,” he said.
A bill sponsored by Les Republicans on maintaining religious neutrality within staff in the public school sector is up for a vote in the Senate, as early as next week.
“There is a need to discuss neutrality in public schools, without hate, without weakness. The subject has not been dealt with sufficiently,” he stressed.
During question time on Tuesday, Prime Minister Edouard Philippe addressed the National Assembly, rejecting accusations that the government had an ambiguous stance when it came to religion in schools.
Philippe said the government preferred to focus on avoiding radicalisation, and school absence because of religious community pressure.
He was attempting to head off a new controversy over the question of secularism and whether or not to allow mothers wearing the Islamic headscarf to accompany their children’s classes on school outings.
Ruling party divided on issue
The French state and church were officially separated by law in 1905 to give form to the concept of secularism rooted in the 1789 French Revolution.
In 2004, the government prohibited the wearing of conspicuous religions symbols in public schools and banned the hijab, a garment that covers a woman's hair but leaves her face exposed, from classrooms and government offices.
Education Minister Jean-Michel Blanquer stressed on Sunday that "the law does not prohibit women wearing headscarves to accompany children", referring to a state council ruling from 2013.
But he also indicated that "the headscarf itself is not desirable in our society" because of "what it says about the status of women, what it says about our values."
Government spokeswoman Sibeth Ndiaye also weighed in, saying it was important to allow space for exchanges between women who wear headscarves and those who do not, as this promoted "inclusivity".
Minister suggests Islamist provocation
Two incidents in the past week have lead to a further revival of this debate.
Last Friday, far-right National Rally (RN) minister Julien Odoul provoked widespread outrage when he posted a video on Twitter of him confronting a woman who accompanied pupils last Friday to the regional parliament in Bourgogne-Franche-Comte in eastern France.
Citing "secular principles" in the wake of the killings in Paris this month of four police staff by a radicalised convert to Islam, he insisted the woman, whose son was among the group, remove her headscarf.
Members of the RN then walked out of the chamber before issuing a press statement denouncing "an Islamist provocation".
Fatima E., speaking to the press for the first time since the incident told France Info on Tuesday that she thought it was a joke until she saw how the students were reacting.
“They were really shocked and traumatised,” she said, and even though she didn’t want to give in, she eventually realized it was better if she left the room, only to be confronted in the corridor by another former member of the National Rally party.
“I was shaking from head to toe,” she said, going on to say that she now has a bad opinion of “what is called the Republic”.
Regional parliament speaker Marie-Guite Dufay, criticised Odoul's actions, saying neither the law of the country nor the rules of the chamber prohibited a member of the public wearing a headscarf.
Dufay denounced a "surge of hatred" and what she described as "undignified behaviour" on the part of a lawmaker.
Fire station refuses school visit
Then on Monday, a visit by a group of school students to the main fire station in Creil, north of Paris, was cancelled outright because two of the mothers accompanying the group were wearing an Islamic hijab.
The director of Regional Fire and rescue service (SDIS) said it was a simple case of misinterpretation on behalf of the fire station chief and that it was regrettable that it had happened.
“The women were wearing a simple headscarf, known as hijab,” Eric de Valroger President of the SDIS told AFP.
“I think the chief was just trying to do his job, and apply the law,” he went on.
One of the women made a complaint to the fire service, saying she was “shocked” over their refusal to allow her to enter the building.
Valroger, who is also the vice-president of the Republicans party in the Val d’Oise region later said the woman had since spoken to the fire station chief and he had apologized and things had calmed down.
Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morningSubscribe