India’s vernacular reporters unearth devastating reality of Covid in rural areas
The real impact of India's Covid-19 surge on rural areas has begun to emerge thanks to vernacular media journalists reporting from the devastated countryside, where 70 percent of the population of 1.4 billion people live.
Using journalism’s oldest tools, journalists have been unravelling firsthand the scale of the havoc in many of India’s 650,000 villages where a highly infectious strain of the coronavirus has spread.
“These are reporters without fear,” media analyst Shivaji Sarkar, with Mangalayatan University, told RFI. “Freelance journalists in small towns are the backbone of vernacular newsrooms and it is they who are at the front-lines now. Kudos to them."
Coronavirus has killed 266,000 people and infected 24 million by a latest official tally in the world’s second worst-affected country.
Dainik Bhaskar, India’s largest-selling Hindi language newspaper, knocked on the doors of villagers in agrarian states to try to reveal the full story.
“Almost every home has people with flu or a cough and their only hope are doctors,” it reported from Rajasthan's Nagaur district.
The daily said 31 of 49 people in three Nagaur hamlets died without being tested for Covid.
Nav Bharat Times, published a similar report from Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state.
“Most homes in four districts have people with Covid-like symptoms but they have neither been tested nor treated,” the mass-circulation Hindi daily added.
Jansatta, another vernacular broadsheet, had a similar story from Uttar Pradesh, where Covid has killed 16,369 people, according to an official count.
"Those graves went in as deep as 10 feet. Even though a grave space cannot be recycled before 2.5 years, we have started burying fresh bodies on top of these graves at six feet.”— The Wire (@thewire_in) May 8, 2021
And this is the story of just two graveyards in Ahmedabad.https://t.co/03y1iiFIW8
Covid deaths were largely under-reported, the leading Gujarati-language paper said, giving dates, numbers and details in a tell-all news dispatch.
In Bihar state, intrepid journalists published what they asserted were verified photographs of hospital staff dumping infected bodies into a river.
You can hide and fudge data, but you cannot hide bodies as they float on rivers and leave you nowhere to hide . I meet a young cowherd at the edge of the Ganga who tells me about the bodies he sees every day. Tracking India's uncounted COVID deaths for @themojostory pic.twitter.com/XOm8No39vn— barkha dutt (@BDUTT) May 14, 2021
In contrast, English-language national newspapers faced criticism for not doing enough to call out India’s rural misery.
Analysts such as Sarkar said media groups eager to grab state advertisements appeared reluctant to report the extent of the catastrophe.
The federal government daily spends more than 222,000 euros on publicity while India’s 29 states too have deep pockets for self-promotion.
“Major parts of the Indian media have abdicated their oversight duty at every stage of the Covid-19 saga over the last year,” said Policy Times, an online publication.
Anupama Jha, a former executive director of Transparency International’s Indian arm said English-language papers seemed content reporting only the urban crisis.
“Journalists in the metros lack the sensitivity and I also feel they do not want to get on the wrong side of the government,” she told RFI, warning that “armchair journalism” was useless at a time of the pandemic.
India has drawn criticism for its inability to counter the deadly surge or vaccinate a sizable chunk of its population in time.
Global donors rushed aid following news reports of oxygen and medical shortages killing people in city hospitals but not much of the handouts have reached the impoverished countryside.
Daily newsletterReceive essential international news every morningSubscribe